A third X-Files movie could provide closure to Mulder and Scully's story before the upcoming reboot by Ryan Coogler, which they deserve, CBR analyses.
Ryan Coogler's announcement of an X-Files reboot has raised concerns among fans about the quality and originality of the show. He plans to remount the series with a diverse cast. However, the news of the reboot underscores the need for a third X-Files movie to provide closure for Scully and Mulder's story.
Creator Chris Carter had previously written a script for another X-Files film, and a third movie could tie up loose ends left by the revival's controversial finale. The revival, consisting of Seasons 10 and 11, received mixed reviews, with stand-out episodes overshadowed by botched character arcs and incohesive mythology. The Season 11 finale, "My Struggle IV," featured shocking twists that left beloved characters as victims and did a disservice to Scully's character.
The X-Files Season 11 received a lackluster reception from both critics and fans. The season's mentioned reliance overpowered nostalgia, despite a few stand-out episodes. The Season 11 finale, "My Struggle IV," left many loose ends, including the characters' fates and Scully's pregnancy, and complicated the possibility of a third movie. The messy mythology of the revival's final episodes was a disservice to Scully's feminist icon status, as she was reduced to a "baby vessel" for an easy heartstring pull.
Despite criticisms, a third X-Files movie with a Monster of the Week-style plot, according to the website, would allow for flexibility and could find a way to wrap up loose ends from Season 11. While Anderson does not wish to return for more seasons, she is open to a movie, as is Duchovny.
In conclusion, Scully and Mulder are the heart of The X-Files, and their skeptic and believer dynamic is what sets the show apart. The chemistry between Gillian Anderson and David Duchovny is also highlighted as impossible to replicate. Therefore, it would be unwise to reboot the show without first giving the original characters a proper send-off.